Desk rejection reddit. (microbiology, virology).

Desk rejection reddit This typically occurs when the manuscript does not meet the journal’s scope, quality standards, or ethical guidelines. I did research a lot and my work did align with the field on interest for the journal but I just wanna know if it's a no, how long before I know it? Outright rejecting? A few days to a couple of weeks. Off the cuff my main reasons for desk rejection are; Plagiarism. As she was being walked out her boss had the balls to ask if she had time for a few questions about her workload before she left. r/StandingDesk. Is this what usually editors say to please authors even when the papers have quality issues (or any other problems like out of scope)? My favourite manuscript was desk rejected by three journals in the space of two weeks, which was super deflating at the time. In the prior year, about 30% of the papers were on one of JOINs or TIME SERIES or GPUs. If the status goes from "With editor" directly to "Decision in process", that usually indicates a desk rejection If the review time is unusually short, that probably also indicates a rejection Revisions typically lead to acceptance High publication fees often imply high acceptance (but also possibly a predatory journal) View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Personally I always give a reason, but clearly that may vary. Meanwhile most of my friends already have jobs. If you need to, put the rejection and the MS aside for a week. I know others who have had similarly difficult experiences before peer review at eLife. He is paid 80k a year and its totally remote. I just went through 8 desk rejections and ended up publishing in an open How do you deal with immediate desk rejections with no substantial reasoning provided? In line with the question, I am unsure whether or not the scientific results of my article were sufficient My review paper just got desk rejected a second time after waiting for 2 weeks. Digg. So recently got an ipad and the pencil (6th gen ipad and 1st gen pencil) to work more efficiently (i can't stand sitting at my desk all day) and the palm rejection is being kinda weird? I have no issues with it on the canvas cuz it messes Now 6 months after submission, I have just received the rejection. Some of the most cited papers in VLDB are on JOINs or TIME SERIES or GPUs. Also important to distinguish between desk rejections and rejections after Unfortunately, I had a paper with a journal for about 2 months only to have it be desk rejected. A rejection is no longer based on relevance to the journal's scope or the impact of your work, but to their bottom line. Posted by u/kostas_k84 - 2 votes and 10 comments It was clearly communicated what phase 1 entails. It took them a month to send mine to review and three months to get reviewers comments in the first round of revisions. ReddIt. I submitted a paper yesterday afternoon and I woke up to a desk rejection email this morning (less than 24 hours later). When I sold forklifts, I would say, “I’ll be in your area tomorrow, so if it’s ok I’ll just take a look at your fleet and write up a service proposal to send you. 5 and 7. Just got a straight-up desk rejection of a recently submitted paper. Posted by u/BigBoyRusty95 - 20,675 votes and 543 comments I had an article that, objectively, was deserving of publication in a high profile journal. We conducted our I need a solid headset with preferably stereo speakers (and preferably circumaural if such a thing exists in the professional world) with really good noise rejection. I find it's better for one's well-being to actually start with a ranked list of journals to which to submit. Most journal usually do not reconsider resubmission. Get what you can out of the reviewer comments and submit to the next journal - perhaps you need to explain the motivation a bit better. Sometimes it takes me a week after being assigned to even do a first read and desk reject or decide to send for review. Is such a long waiting period normal? Received this email for NIPS 2020 rejection and the reason for rejection is - 1. Post any questions you have, there are lots of redditors with admissions knowledge waiting to help. 03 for the past year and I've gotten my resume and cover letter appraised from my peers and parents. My hotel is currently hiring. Top tier journals often get desk rejects out within a week, which is Yesterday we received a desk rejection notice from NeurIPS because our paper is several lines over the 8-page limit. (None of these is you personally necessarily. Five rejections later (1 desk rejection, 4 proper reviews), we eventually settled for publishing in the standard archival journal in our field, which we probably could have done almost two years earlier if we'd have just gone there to start. I'm currently on Day 11 and it's still "under consideration TU Delft masters in Robotics desk rejection on basis of CGPA . 3 days for a desk rejection is annoying; 6 months for rejection can be devastating to someone's timeline. Your perspective is crucial, and rejection is a harsh word for something that is part of the territory. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Minecraft; Pokimane; Halo Infinite; Desk rejection is the worst! But you have to move on, target another journal, don't try to convince the 1st one to reconsider. Tumblr. Cars related discussion is not allowed Im in a field with a lot of desk rejects (doesn’t even get sent to reviewers), but I’ve still gotten all my manuscripts to land in decent journals. A good example of why a paper might not get desk rejection but still not be publishable is the following. Simply cut out the Conclusion. A Reddit community for those who work from home! Helpful tips and discussions on This subreddit is temporarily closed in protest of Reddit killing third party apps, see /r/ModCoord and /r/Save3rdPartyApps for more information. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. In all cases, I got editorial desk rejections. Motorbikes related posts here. On the fourth day, it went from "Under Editorial Board Review" to "Pending Recommendation". I submitted my study to 5 journals b/w 1. While the research has novelty, it is on a now curable disease in specialty A (meaning there is no more debate on whether to treat) and our primary outcome is associated with, but not entirely tied to, clinical improvement in specialty B. A few days later, I was informed that I was rejected because I was "overqualified". You submitted the article, the editor did not feel it was a good fit, and they chose not to forward to reviewers, which is a choice editors make when they feel confident the article either is Felt like maybe I wasn’t cut out for this. I'm sorry to hear that. Rejection after review is almost surely because of the reviewers' decision, regardless on whether the topic of your paper suits their journal or not. In brief. The desk isn't right for me, the work seem to be endless, going into work early for a head start, skipping breaks, working partially during lunch, staying late a few mins to finish touches still doesn't get the work completed. Could be because they think the study is no good or that they think it is not relevant (for that journal) or that it is considered too low impact. This work means the world to my team. More posts you may like As I understand, this may indicate that the peer-review process is complete and the editor(s) could be deciding whether to accept/reject my manuscript. It's quite a niche topic so I understand why: Quali study on the perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors of professional esports athletes when it comes to their health. If you’ve ever tried to get an appointment as an outside vendor with a decision maker, you fear At least it seems the paper went out for review (and this wasn't a desk rejection). reddit's new API changes kill third party apps that offer accessibility features, mod tools, and other features not found in the first party app. My job progression is as follows Got a bachelors degree in film in 2011 worked as a marketing video editor and producer for a small marketing company but I needed to make more money Rejection is never easy, but the way it’s delivered can make a significant difference. This year NeuRIPS has over 10000 submissions (double the size of ICML 2020), so even after desk-rejection phase, which assuming 85% of this amount will receive full reviewing process, we still have 8500 submissions left. Did not receive a rejection email and never emailed back asking them what happened (because usually if they don't reach out in few days it means rejection). Sometimes it takes time. Not only do you need to try your luck at another journal, you also receive An exponential distribution seems likely, so the mean and standard deviation would be the same, and the probability of a desk rejection later than 3 weeks is about 17%, if the mean time to desk rejection is 1. After several months of work and seeking advice from various experts, we significantly improved the paper. Rejection rates at these journals generally reflect the percentage of people applying as stretch goals (i. I forwarded it to my boss and jokingly said this is a really passive aggressive way to say you are unhappy with my performance r/MuleSoft is the official reddit gathering place for all things MuleSoft. " I received a desk rejection today from their editor. Introduction. The worse case scenario is rejection You could also look for an internship as well. I've found that cover letters can literally be the difference between acceptance and desk rejection at many Q1 journals. I’ve been applying for 6 months on and off (I’m also a teacher online making $10/hr and I also work for a chat/email desk online) but I’m looking for something more stable. Learning that papers get published even after 10+ rejections, I'm gonna guess that rejection is just a part of the process and that I should just go back to the drawing board and figure out how to improve my manuscript. no title, abstract, list of authors (if they want them as seperate documents) --- the nice people at the journal, but most likely not anyone near the editor, will likely just send you a nice email and you can ask to withdraw (I missed something once, nice person emailed me). Zu mir: 32m, Master Maschinenbau (1. Reasons of desk rejection. But then go back, reread and look for any possible improvements, and then send it off. Do your research on journals' scope to minimize desk rejects. The Reddit Law School Admissions Forum. I'm currently a few months in a 12 month probation right now and I'm considering to self reject myself on probation. And these things take time. 5 Jahre Masterand (MA im Unternehmen), nebenberufliche Promotion, L6S und MTM Zertifikate, sehr gute Work (Paid)11; Break; 23 hr/wk, 8 wk/yrCashier and Receptionist, Nail SalonGreeted customers and serviced front desk; organized cash register;janitorial jobs such as cleaning bathroom; answered calls and madeappointments Order Rejection Details . Gaming headsets have all been a little staticy on the play back. ) Yes I applied directly got an interview did the interview. My advisor—whose name is known by everyone in my field—gave me this same advice when I got my first desk rejection. Hoping to hop on a call, and we don't have to disclose identities, just to keep things private. I felt it didn't go well because it was relatively short. Read a quite a few stories ranging all the way from no rejection to 13 rejections (and ending up in IF greater than the first). Many if not most papers get desk rejected by at least one journal, so it does not mean it is unpublishable garbage. If you get too emotionally connected to the inevitable cycle of rejection you will only end up damaging your mental health. Enjoy your holidays. Even though clearing the overall criteria of 75 percent for indian students with a cgpa of 8. Looking for alternative public health journals but lacking confidence after the first rejection. 5 years? 2 years? Initial submission and been a while now hanging at ‘Editor Decision Started’ in one of the npg journals. But get drunk tonight. Wᴇʟᴄᴏᴍᴇ ᴛᴏ ʀ/SGExᴀᴍs – the largest community on reddit discussing education and student life in Singapore Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Probably wouldn't hurt and reiterate that to whomever you speak to regarding any potential interviews. During this process, I realized a few things: My "fun" story about a paper: I submitted to journal X, and got a desk rejection, but with the editor saying they liked the paper and it might be a better fit at journal Y. Today, I was told the paper got desk rejected since "I did not use the correct template and over used the margins". About an hour later someone from HR comes up to her and asked her to clean out her desk and leave immediately. I made some changes to the manuscript and submitted to another journal and Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Desk rejection due to insufficient space? Hi, I just got desk rejected and the reason provided was that there is insufficient space to publish. But then you get back up and move on. Part of my job description is to interview and send rejection letters. If you have too many articles to handle, desk reject more of them and let the authors find someone else. Like any other rejection in your life. VK. LINE. Now I'm confused Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. The scope of the journals was not an issue here because very similar studies were published before and were heavily cited in my own literature review. x), 5 Jahre Berufserfahrung (Projektleiter, seit etwas über einem Jahr Vertriebsingenieur), davor 2. Thanks a lot for your inputs, everyone. The reason is that we didn’t provide proofs that one of the authors has enough experience in this topic. e. IT help desk is full time, assuming regular school hours, starting is $20-$23/hr. CSCareerQuestions protests in The extremely unhelpful front desk employee told me that I was never accepted and that essentially I was lying about being accepted in person. rejection: Sometimes rejection doesn't mean "Never," just "Not right now. Sounds like a desk rejection. Check out the sidebar for intro guides. All things related to automobiles that move on two wheels. Or check it out in the app stores what great timing. I have a built in desk nook next to my closet in my room, and I just padded the walls inside the booth and hung up a curtain on the outside of the booth. That was a complete bs It's not always that bad and, as evertyhing in academia, field-dependent. I similarly had a completely fact-free desk rejection, which we appealed, and where other editors agreed with our criticism but said, "oh we don't think this has the impact for eLife anyway". I take at least 15 minutes for coffee, and sit in silence. Every single one of the major companies are just a circus where the clowns wear suits. Some nature editors are lot slower than others. A few minutes later, he shows up, refuses to I started help desk about 4 months ago and now I’m tech support with very low call volume and remote. I had a desk reject at a mid-range journal and then someone told me to send it to a higher one and I got accepted with only minor revisions. On January 24, 2022, Redditgifts was officially closed and we are no longer running exchanges. The last rejection was during the first months of covid quarantine and the darkest period of my life. Keep in mind that if you submit to a Q1 journal, the acceptance rate is quite low, so don't take rejection personally. As long as you arent some lecherous twat douche canoe, the worst thing that taking a respectful shot can do - is make that person feel good about themselves. I have a friend who works service desk for a enterprise organization. StandingDesk stands (heh) against Reddit corporate takeovers but this sub's current state would be better than whatever Reddit Inc would do, so. If your paper underwent the review process, you have hopefully great feedback to make it even better for the next journal! Don't give up! Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Is it safe to assume that this will be an unfortunate desk rejection, i. I had to rewrite it as well in that time because it had been so long, new data had emerged (it's a systematic review). I think some agencies are improving faster than others but recruitment processes are for sure a major weakness for the whole system and I think one we massively i stopped into local ikea today to show this reference image for my reception desk! business planner told me it was an ikea hack- use their desk and then build a ponywall in front of it and finish it with this slatboard facing (available at home depot). Some general tips for dealing with paper rejection I summarized in a short video, perhaps it's useful to you: View community ranking In the Top 50% of largest communities on Reddit. An hour later a multiple attempts at getting someone who could help finally got the bill. I've been writing for as long as I can remember, but for the past few years, I've really been putting a foot forward toward publication through writing contests and submissions. Focusing specifically on English teaching in Japan, you really do not need to take rejection from any of them personally. 🏃🏾🏃‍♀️🏃🏻‍♂️ _____ Users can trade their NFTs on the in-app marketplace. My manuscript was under consideration for 43 days! And "editor decision started" for 7 days. I had to call the help desk to get the details. Rejection is normal and can happen for various reasons, but most importantly "noise". Ask Question Asked 1 year, 6 months ago. A colleague of ours had submitted an article two days prior and received a desk rejection about two weeks ago. Or check it out in the app stores   Nature Desk Rejection Timeline? STEM First time submitted a manuscript to Nature and was told by colleagues that editorial/desk rejections come very fast within 2-3 business days. Since she thought this might happen, she cleaned out out her desk last week. Short Answer: Desk rejects are quick, but if it goes out to review, then rejections tend to take as long as any other first-round outcome. I’ve tried jpg, jpeg, heic, and even RGB formats. I wished some wise elderly would prevent from doing that. I was actually surprised at this as I had researched this journal thoroughly and thought a desk rejection based on quality of research was much more likely considering this was a higher impact journal (not that I think that my research is bad, but I imagine high impact journals have the privilege of only accepting the best of the best). They apparently got 150% of last year's submissions. This subreddit is temporarily closed in protest of Reddit killing third party apps, see /r/ModCoord and /r/Save3rdPartyApps for more information. Felt a lot less worse and got working on the manuscript again 2 days later. Given that that desk is usually manned by someone whose main task is to keep people away from the decision makersthe new title might be more apt. the companies are wanting a lot for very little, and most all of them are not even sending automatic rejection emails anymore even after you're in their interview process. There's unfortunately still a significant portion of luck involved to get proper reviewers who take the time to understand your work and make constructive comments, but those do happen. (🇮🇳-🏍️) Place for all Indian riders to discuss news, reviews and motorcycle trips. It's the "Maybe" that leaves you stuck in limbo. Or check it out in the app stores   Or, could the length of my mansuscript be a possible reason for rejection? Could a manuscript be overqualified for a journal? Our journals have ridiculously high rejection rates, and a lot of papers get desk rejections with no or minimal comments. I wanted to ask for some advice on how to interpret the feedback. Here is where it gets tricky, though, that 3rd meeting could be a purely technical interview or a culture fit test, or both. Within a couple days, I received an immediate desk rejection The Reddit Law School Admissions Forum. Hearing "No" frees you to move on. All the manuscripts are automatically screened before I Y'all, I wouldn't work out with the sexiest guy in the world at 4 am. Don't be like me I'm 37 years old. If oth reviews recommend the paper to not to progress to phase 2 ( because there are issues which cannot be resolved within the review cycle), then the meta reviewer will take a I may have given you my gear/setup rundown before, but it's an AT4040 into an Apogee Duet 2. Print. After each rejection I sent it to a journal with a higher IF, until it went in to the second highest journal in the field and was accepted after one round of revisions. I visited the admission office that same day and was fortunate enough to meet with the director. Hi Leute, bin aktuell auf Jobsuche im Raum NRW, aber bisher hagelts nur Absagen. Easier said than done when in the moment, I know. So I submitted to journal Y, and got a desk rejection, but with the editor saying they liked the paper and it /r/secretsanta and Reddit Gifts were started in 2009 to provide a Secret Santa exchange for the Reddit community. Reddit India bikes lovers gather here. The best place on Reddit for admissions advice. The pendulum CSCareerQuestions protests in solidarity with the developers who made third party reddit apps. My first paper also got rejected 3 times before settling on a new open access journal that is a sub-journal to a I recently got a desk rejection for a manuscript I submitted to a journal in the field of urban systems and analysis. Mix. Our interdisciplinary clinical research has been desk-rejected for 6 times in a row. While it is always a bummer to have a desk rejection, especially from a journal you perceive to be a good fit, nothing you describe sounds unfair here. Or check it out in the app stores   One of my old bosses used to allow himself 10 minutes to yell at rejection letters, and call the reviewers idiots, before moving on and improving the manuscript, that worked for him! First desk rejection help. It will have to be positioned quite near the keyboard with as I have a small desk. I worked on this paper for about 2 years by the time I submitted it. This can get sticky as there are shit reviewers out there. I’ve also had the case of waiting three months for editor and desk rejection so just forget about the paper for a while. Once I put the hand-written proposal together, I’d drop it on their desk in person with my business card. I’m in the market for a new desk, I spend basically 10-12 hours sitting at my desk. 21 votes, 10 comments. I completely agree. However, you have to be a very special breed to take a rejected paper and submit it unchanged to another I am just curious and want to ask if anyone else applied for ASU MCS Fall 2023 session and got a reject already? My application went into review on 1st October and was rejected on 5th October. How to Handle Rejection - A Senior Editor's Guide upvotes · comments. That means that journal was good enough for their precious work. But I have to admit, the desk rejection was both disappointing and relieving, because, if desk rejection takes this long, then how long would it take to actually get published? 1. I was sitting at my desk and got a rejection letter. This submission is summarily rejected because: - The paper is not formatted according to the NeurIPS requirements or it is not sufficiently anonymized. ” This required nothing from them (or so they thought, muahahaha!). But I find it unprofessional to reject a revised manuscript on Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I’ve applied for a TON of customer service jobs and every time I get the rejection email “we’re moving forward” blah blah. If I am desk rejecting your paper it is Ultimately, I realized how important rejections are for science and that the rejection wasn't about me as a person or what I was capable of (as others have said, there are many reasons for a rejection and not all are to do with the quality of the paper itself). I recently submitted a paper on which I worked on for quite a long time to a social sciences journal. Users equip NFT Sneakers – walk, jog or run outdoors to earn tokens and NFTs. I responded immediately with: "Honest mistake, first-time NeurIPS submitters! Please give us a chance. After reviewing your application and considering all of our open positions, we think this is the best fit, We always keep an open mind during the course of the interview process, but at this time we are primarily considering you for TDO. Post latest news, reviews, opinions, pics, etc here. Nature Desk Rejection Timeline? First time submitted a manuscript to Nature and was told by colleagues that editorial/desk rejections come very fast within 2-3 business days. We've received your resume and would like to consider you for the Trading Desk Operations (TDO) role. He was extremely helpful, and told me to contact him directly and to ignore the front desk staff. However, the paper was on doing JOINs with TIME SERIES with GPUs. It's gotten good feedback when I presented it at conferences and people who have read it have found it interesting. mid-level providers, practice managers, administrators, billers and front desk staff members have questions about coding. That's pretty strange, I Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets And if you want to get published at top journals, you must do it or face desk rejection. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets Paper at risk of desk rejection due to missing volunteer. E. “DESINO L Shaped Gaming Desk 59 inch Computer Corner Desk PC Writing Table Gamer Workstation for Home Office” Edit: as far as other desks, I’ve resorted to building my own. (By minimal I mean the kind of fluff already mentioned, "the volume of submissions is especially high", "we're currently not accepting any further papers on topic/philosopher x", and so forth. It was then desk rejected by three other journals for being ever so slightly out of scope. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. I got another manuscript rejection today too. 12. The feedback we received was generic, asking for more experiments, ablation studies, and citing unclear writing and motivation blah blah. Or check it out in the app stores and got a rejection today with the offer to transfer the manuscript directly to a variety of other journals. TU Delft is explicitly anal about cgpa criteria. By the time I finish browsing Reddit, I'm either in a good mood or fired up, which makes me ready to check my email. I desk reject somewhere in the region of 30-40% of submissions. While I am appreciative that the review time was relatively short (~30 days), I suspect that this may indicate a desk-rejection is imminent. I had a manuscript submitted to Nature, and desk-rejected. After that, I usually catch up on the Wikipedia homepage, weather, news, and Reddit. For school, job, etc. You can receive them for good, bad, and downright silly reasons - but it's a guarantee one way or the other. How have you dealt with rejection in the past, and how do you get The rejection sucks and there’s nothing that makes it suck less but at least try to not take it as a poor reflection on you and more just a system that’s far far far from perfect. If you have to get a rejection, it's always better to get the near-instant bench rejection so that you can turn the manuscript around to another journal where it might have a better chance. But it happens all the time. Instead, I try to ground myself before diving into technology. Many years ago, I applied for a Help Desk position at a company that was much closer to where I lived (so shorter commute was a big driving factor) through a recruiter. Email. Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Even if it is rejection. You don't really need any prior experience for help desk since it's more of any entry level position. Without desk-rejection we will essentially overload reviewers and the risk of having low-quality reviews is very high. This experience highlights how some people might choose to express their disinterest in a more hurtful manner. You submit to a highly specialized paper to a journal. Or check it out in the app stores   I stood in the fancy lobby, marveling at the small water feature they had installed next to the receptionist's desk, having been told that the manager who was to interview me was on his way. . That's a normal timeframe for a rejection with reviews. Welcome to r/LearnJapanese, *the* hub on Reddit for learners of the Japanese Language. Reply reply As an official Fidelity customer care channel, our community is the best way to get help on Reddit with your questions about investing with Fidelity You will sometimes have to figure out that what the rejection says isn’t the actual rejection reason, but that comes with experience. I'm currently on Day 11 and it's still "under consideration" with no reviewers contacted or any editorial decision. Viber. grants, etc. Then, after desk rejection, suddenly this journal is not worth citing anymore? Too personal and too unprofessional. Has anyone had this before? What can lead to this Understanding desk rejection is crucial for authors as it helps them identify common pitfalls in their submissions, align their research with journal aims, and improve their A desk-reject means your manuscript has been rejected by a journal without being sent out for review. The company I work at posted an internship recently; unfortunately it was filled internally by a Also, learn to reject early and quickly. Much better for the price. I will use it for discord etc. Posted by u/WaVeYgUrL - 44 votes and 10 comments View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit [iPad] palm rejection being wonky . LONG LIVE REDDITGIFTS! Editor here. The reason given is that the paper does not fit the scope of the journal despite the content being closely related. Then I submitted it to Science, it was rejected after the 1st round review, - 1 postive, 1 extremely negative. Desk rejection refers to the process where a submitted manuscript is rejected by the editor without being sent for peer review. Hi all, new to TOS, my orders keep getting rejected and don't include additional details to know why. Hi there, does anyone work at the Trade Desk? I have a few questions and would love to pick your brain. If it does not suit the journal, it will be rejected without review to begin with (desk rejection). He does maybe 10 hours of actual work per week because he does mainly tier 2 and 3 tickets and he knows the system inside out and backwards. If we would have gotten a desk reject on the initial submission in a useful delay, I would have accepted the decision. Dealing with Rejection . Do you have any idea if it is possible to submit to the same journal again after showing enough proof regarding my Got a rejection email today for one of my papers. fun! (microbiology, virology). Or check it out in the app stores the paper was desk rejection, and third time was rejected and will not be possible to resubmit. The rejection Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Gaming sub journal for getting sent out for review, and odds for acceptance after? I was hoping the desk rejection is a big hinch where most rejected manuscripts get rejected, but stats would be awesome! Edit: Title should Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Indian Bikes Reddit community. 5 Jahre Werkstudent und 0. 😂 I haven't heard of anyone who has received a desk reject but someone tweeted a supposed info from reviewers on the 12th that they have essentially finished that process and will start informing on desk rejects soon. I submitted a paper, and got an immediate desk reject as “out of scope”. Hi everyone, I am a PhD student and close to finish my degree. Academics are trained to find flaws in everything and be very critical. We got accepted with minor revisions at the first journal we submitted to (~14 IF), though we queried them beforehand to see if they were interested (they were) so that lowered the chances of a desk rejection. g. , is not being sent out for review? the journal. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Traffic noise, stuff going on in the house, all that certainly gets picked up on the mic. 7 weeks. Rejection doesn’t equal failure!! Failure only happens when you quit trying to succeed!! That also means that you weren’t meant to have this position. The editor is roughly familiar with your field, but not enough to know whether (a) you're just reinventing the wheel, or (b) you are interpreting your sources accurately. Obviously you have to be some what computer literate, they may ask you some very minor technical questions depending on the I’m so freaking annoyed. 0 IF, starting with the highest and coming down with each rejection. You get two reviews. Also you have to assume people have been off for the holiday. 500 bucks in building materials can make you pretty much whatever desk you want, short of a Mahogany masterpiece. I've maintained a GPA of 4. My first PhD paper was under review for 15 months before I withdrew it because the journal couldn't get reviewers. No other comments on methodologies and technical contents were given. they hope they'll get in but don't expect to) and very selective attention to impact by the editorial staff, rather than it being There was a doctoral student years ago who wore a dress at her defence that comprised of rejection letters. (Postdoc in materials science in a European university) Because the rejections are invisible and the acceptances obvious, you can get a warped sense of how "bad" a rejection is. ask if they have any feedback or tips and maybe give some light positive feedback of my experience Understanding Desk Rejection. So, OP sends a paper to the journal. Today's demand for certified professional coders (CPCs) is growing as many jobs in One option is that you could just miss some of the information they need. I went for a hike and am now on Reddit, drinking beer and eating crisps in bed (feeling quite disillusioned). Advertise on Reddit; Shop Give special attention to how you're drafting your cover letters; that's your chance to tell the editor your big findings and why it is a good fit for their journalthen they can read the manuscript with that in mind. there should be an offer or rejection after this. I’ve tried many different photos. You take a couple hours to be disappointed or upset and mourn the rejection. Got on Reddit, and asked people how many rejections it takes to get their first article out. She seemed very happy talking to you (which we don't want to read into, but at the same time, you obviously don't creep her out or anything). I'm not sure but they may be checking all the desk rejects to make sure they are justified before informing. Now, two years have passed, and that stupid paper only got so far 15 citations or so. Rejection doesn’t mean you did anything wrong at all, a lot Take a day or two off, embrace this rejection process, enhance the paper, resubmit it either to the same journal (Please change the title and modify the paper so it would have a chance to be read by new reviewers and don’t be like my supervisor who insisted on submitting the paper to the same journal with the same title and got it rejected Third year in Neuroscience. But no one around me has received any email related to desk rejections (like if they passed or not) yet, nor has anyone on twitter or reddit stated that. I just had a paper STEPN is a Web3 lifestyle app with Social-Fi and Game-Fi elements that uses a dual-token system. As an example, I manage a suite of 6 journals and our flagship journal receives approximately 1200 submissions a year and the acceptance rate is about 9%. I called, got transferred multiple times, once to a credit card company. Exactly! And as long as you have the right attitude, girls will let you get away with a lot of things. Reposting to correct title As title says - first submission to a prestigious journal and at the desk review stage (before it goes through any internal or peer review), they said its relevant to the journal and an important topic, but 'does not currently meet sufficient key criteria that would make it more likely to succeed in peer review'. Rejection Letter for Location Hello has anyone applied in California and received a letter of rejection for location stating "PC delivery proximity considerations of our at home programs due to the minimum wage requirements in Los Angeles County? What to expect from The reviewers got their review assignments, that means desk rejections are finished and authors should be notified. Extremely frustrating since desk rejections don't give you the kind of feedback that a reviewer rejection would to improve the manuscript. We welcome anyone curious to learn more about unified connectivity and an API-led approach. I'm sorry you had a rough outright rejection from eLife. Congrats and good luck. Forbidden” any photo I upload. I realized resizing warps the photo so I went photo shooting yesterday and made sure the settings on my camera were correct. Most common form of rejection I've had is editors not feeling the paper is a good fit (basically journals with high impact factor who only want the sexiest stuff). Telegram. As a reviewer, I'd insta-reject any RNR that didn't have one. OP got a bench rejection by the action editor without additional reviewers. After two weeks, we received a desk rejection (without an invitation to resubmit), citing a lack of proper benchmarking and a narrow scope. This prepares you for the often inevitable rejection from the beginning. So if you haven't heard anything from a Within a couple days, I received an immediate desk rejection saying that the paper is not developed enough, nothing else. For relationship rejection: Rejection is a favor. This number is Best mic for rejection is the one that is off or muted on the desk General consensus would be that less sensitive mics (dynamics) when given a strong input signal (strong singer for eg) reject better than highly sensitive mics (Condensers) if there is a lot of stage wash. but also want to have some audio for some videos I occasionally record. For me desk rejection is a trigger for sending another paper there. And I am reminded how that feeling of disappointment with yourself is 100x worse than any rejection could be. I was expecting a desk rejection letter soon Nature Communications (passed editor, strong rejection by reviewers) Nature Nanotechnology (passed editor, mild rejection by reviewers) Nature (reject w/out review) Science (reject w/out review) Nature Nanotechnology (awaiting results) We are up to 7 rejections now after 1 year of resubmitting, rewriting, and performing new experiments. " Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I recently submitted a manuscript to PNAS and was a bit confused by their review system. But, it's important to also be able to differentiate between a clear cut rejection and a situation where even though you got rejected in the moment the girl is still entertaining you. All we ask for is a chance at reviews. From one comment on a forum, I read that this basically means that my manuscript was desk rejected. We've tested a couple headsets which have decent noise rejection while the wearer is speaking, but as soon as they fall silent the gain picks up and amplifies the background chatter. Or check it out in the app stores I know that the desk reject process at Nature-branded journals is a bit more complex than moving a paper from the inbox to the circular file; there is a requirement that all papers are read fully and that decisions (including desk rejections) are View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit [D] NeurIPS Desk Rejection on Aug 4 BECAUSE OF OTHER'S DUAL SUBMISSION! Any thoughts about this new desk rejection policy? Related Topics Machine learning Computer science Information & communications technology Applied science Formal science Technology Science comments We've not-so-recently submitted a manuscript to PNAS, which, after passing quality checks, has remained at the 'Under Editorial Board Review' stage for 33 days now. A desk rejection, particularly at a journal like nature where there are a lot of submission, can definitely take more than a week. I was hoping it had gone to peer review since it had been a month since submission, but it was just a long desk rejection. That said, it's a smaller paper from a side project, with a fairly straightforward story. Artwork rejection :( I keep getting a message saying “upload failed. Post any questions Desk rejects (what you received) boil down to 2 things: perceived quality fit If an editor believes that the paper isn’t good enough to be reviewed, they won’t bother wasting the time of an already stretched (volunteer) reviewer pool. Modified 1 year, 4 months ago. Rejection after peer review is based on whether your work is robust enough - in the view of the reviewers. One should cite papers, not journals. Roughly 1hr20minutes to their central office. Over the past three weeks, NeurIPS 2020 program chairs have tasked area chairs (AC) and senior area chairs (SAC) with the job of summary rejection (aka desk-rejects): ACs did a light read of the papers and identified those they believed would not be accepted, and SACs cross-checked the selections, according to a NeurIPS blog post. This year, despite two acceptances, we faced one rejection (with the fourth review missing) without clear reasons or useful feedback. It’s a data science paper based on quantitative analysis. I've applied to 8 student jobs this past semester to various positions from Desk Assistants to TA's and Research Aides, however, I keep getting rejected. The only way to get a long CV is to accumulate some rejections along the way. Viewed 9k times 7 . The guest came back to desk saying that they wouldn’t give them the receipt and ask if I could speak with them. I think it's safe to say that other prestige journals (Science, Cell, PNAS) have similar desk reject rates. Gaming. (not just reddit) and look up salary benchmarks. ocq uznexbh gewf hnhwe lietc aufami oqrzfi wfltl fbkbbo bvjkdysqk